Chrysler inquiry nears end
Leaky seals may have caused antilock brake problem
By Janet L. Fix
Detroit Free Press Washington Bureau
An investigation into complaints of failed or faulty
antilock brakes on Chrysler minivans and cars is zeroing in
on leaky piston seals as the most likely cause of any
problems.
Chrysler said Wednesday that its investigation had
narrowed the list of possible causes of problems with the
Bendix-10 antilock braking systems it used in 254,185
minivans and 68,000 passenger cars from model years 1990,
1992 and 1993.
``Right now, it appears that the piston seal in the
hydraulic unit is the leading candidate _ but we're not
sure because we haven't finished our tests,'' said Chrysler
spokesman Lindsey Brooke.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is
also investigating the brakes, but would not say where its
tests are leading.
NHTSA has received complaints that problems with the
antilock brakes in those cars and vans contributed to 53
accidents and 26 injuries.
If testing by Chrysler and NHTSA proves that leaky seals
are at fault, the automaker may respond with a voluntary
service action, in which owners would be encouraged to
bring in cars and minivans for testing and possible repair.
Chrysler called ``erroneous'' a Bloomberg Business News
report Tuesday that it was considering a recall of the
minivans and cars.
``No recall is in the works and no service action is in
the works,'' said Randy Edwards, Chrysler's manager for
vehicle safety and emission compliance.
Mike Brownlee, NHTSA's chief investigator, said he'd
hoped NHTSA's investigation would be completed by year-end.
But that was before the lead antilock brake systems
investigator Wolfgang Reinhart, a 20-year NHTSA veteran,
died of a heart attack at age 48.
``We hope to wrap up the investigation soon but
Wolfgang's death six weeks ago left a huge void,'' Brownlee
said Wednesday. ``If you had a tough investigation,
``We hope to wrap up the investigation soon but
Wolfgang's death six weeks ago left a huge void,'' Brownlee
said Wednesday. ``If you had a tough investigation, you
turned to Wolfgang.''
NHTSA's investigation can end in one of three ways: in
an official government recall, a voluntary service action
or no action at all. A recall would be ordered if NHTSA
determines the Chrysler vehicles do not meet legal safety
standards or that a defect poses a safety threat.
Despite consumer claims that the antilock brakes and
backup or basic braking systems failed at the same time,
Chrysler's tests haven't shown any brake system failures.
While a leaky piston seal could lead to less pressure
when drivers step on the brake pedal, Chrysler insists the
brakes don't actually fail, so there is no real safety risk.
As a result, ``NHTSA may finally agree with us this that
there is not an unreasonable risk to safety,'' Edwards said.
The government agency began its minivan investigation in
July 1994. It expanded its review in May to include the
68,000 cars.
The minivans are Chrysler, Plymouth and Dodge models.
The cars are the Chrysler New Yorker, Fifth Avenue and
Imperial; the Eagle Premier; and the Dodge Dynasty and
Monaco models.
Consumer advocates want Chrysler to replace the entire
brake system on the vehicles. They're outraged that many
Chrysler minivan owners paid up to $3,000 to have their
brakes repaired by dealers.
Chrysler conceded that many dealers replaced entire
antilock brake systems when improved diagnostic techniques
have led the automaker to decide that a simpler fix may
have solved the problem.
``There has been so much misdiagnosis by dealers, that
we have been helping them,'' Edwards said. ``Instead of
replacing the entire ABS unit we've minimized the cost and
time of repairs with a piston kit'' that repairs leaky
seals.
Chrysler brake inquiry nears end
Copyright, Detroit Free Press; all rights reserved.
12/7/95
{et
Go back to the Article Index Page